News

Signal Blocked Phone Screenshots After Gemini and Siri AI Started Reading Encrypted Chats

Signal said on November 20 it now blocks screenshots on iOS 27 and Android AI assistants from reading chats. Turning that off breaks its privacy guarantee.

Signal just treated Gemini and Siri like Microsoft Recall: if the operating system can see the screen, the encryption does not matter.

On November 20, Meredith Whittaker wrote that Signal is restricting AI agents built into phones from capturing and storing Signal data. Last year the app blocked screenshots by default so Windows 11 Recall could not keep copies of chats. It is now doing the same on iOS 27, and on Android versions where Signal can detect an assistant trying to read the screen.

Google and Apple, she wrote, are folding Gemini Intelligence and Siri AI Onscreen Awareness into the OS. Those agents scan what is on the display so they can answer questions. Once that scan happens, the messages sit in whatever local database or remote server the OS agent uses. Signal cannot audit that copy. Everyone in the thread is exposed, including people who never opened Gemini.

The switch is optional, and incomplete

People who want screenshots can turn the protection off in Signal's settings. Whittaker's warning is blunt: that choice can expose your contacts' messages to the agents, and it breaks Signal's privacy guarantees. The fix is also incomplete. Screenshot blocking does not stop an agent from reading files already on the device.

On many Android skins, Signal cannot reliably tell a screenshot attempt from a dead button if screenshots are already disabled. The app instead watches for an AI assistant reaching for the screen, then turns on "Screen security." It cannot do even that on macOS. Apple's screenshot APIs, Whittaker wrote, are a pile of deprecations aimed at DRM, not chat apps. For macOS 27, Signal's only advice is to add the app to Excluded Apps under System Settings, Siri.

Techpresso already covered Apple tightening Full Disk Access after agents started reading Mail and Messages. Google's Gemini Mac computer-use window, which we walked through earlier today, is the same instinct on a desktop: the agent sees the screen, you keep a pause button. Signal's argument is that a pause button is not a privacy guarantee.

Muse, accessibility, and a request

Whittaker also called out third-party agents such as Meta's Muse, which she says can use accessibility permissions as a skeleton key. Signal wants two things from Apple, Google, and Microsoft: a documented way for an app to opt out of AI data access (screen, files, notifications, APIs) without breaking the product, and actual specifications for how the agents collect data. Confidential computing, she wrote, is not that.

Until those tools exist, the encrypted messenger's answer is to black out the screenshot. The messages stay in Signal. The OS agent does not get a picture of them, unless you turn that off.

Some offers on this page may be paid placements or contain affiliate links.

Subscribe to Techpresso

Free daily newsletter, read in 5 minutes.

Subscribe free